Is MHJ a buy or sell in dynasty? Seems like a similar situation to JSN from last year, but something about him seems far more unimpressive than JSN. Is it coaching/QB malpractice or more on him?

I agree. He also seemed passive and didn’t use his size as a weapon on jump balls and close plays. The bad usage and his humble approach do concern me. But…a lot of freshman lay low in college until they learn how it works. Then they assert themselves as confident players as sophomores and juniors. Same with regular people. New hires learn the landscape then after a while they assume a bigger role. I’m hoping that’s the case with Marv. If you want to get him I’d let the pundits raise questions about the Cardinals and Kyler, the coaches/usage, and Marvin and get that baked into hopefully a lower price

Buy

That’s your sales pitch when you buy him at a discount

Easily a buy

@TuggerNutts hard to say. Guess it depends on what that manager wants for him. I currently agree with your concerns about him. I do think the coaching/usage was terrible and didn’t match his skill set. There’s always the possibility he isn’t what we as fans thought he was. I’m willing to buy low because he strikes me as a very young guy who wasn’t prepared to assert himself amongst established men as a rookie and he could still grow into a real stud player