12tm SF TEP Dynasty: Smash or Pass? Give: Jayden Reed Get: Jaylen Waddle

I’m a Waddle owner and big Tide fan, but also feel like a realist. Waddle feels like a career low point rn. Waddle has shown the ceiling you dream of for Reed.

Hmm…my knee jerk would be to say Waddle. However, when I really think about it…they’re both in the same position. Talented and explosive but in crowded receiver rooms and won’t likely truly emerge until the room gets less crowded. But when I look past that, I think I’d rather have Reed. 1) he’s got a much more stable QB situation and on a more stabley improving offense 2) he’s not shown to be particularly injury prone (despite the fact that he still does returns) 3) since all of those WRs are going to have contracts that will start expiring next year, the path to emergence seems sooner to me (Waddle may be the same, depending on Washington). With all that said, I think I’d rather have Reed, but I know I’m probably alone in that.

I'd give my Reed for Waddle

Smash

Waddle

Waddle definitely has a higher perceived value right now though

I really like waddle, but even if hills gone, if tua gets hurt he's useless.

Waddle easily for me tbh. At the very least he has more value than Reed, so you could flip him for more