Would you trade Penix for JJ McCarthy and the 2.1 in a QB starved superflex dynasty league? I think I'm going to do it, unless y'all talk me off the cliff.

Sulldaddy 8 hours ago

seems like Penix is going to be okay in ATL. are you rebuilding and need picks? how many teams? pretty good RB draft, I think. its not a terrible trade, just unsure what McCarthy is going to be. im more confident in Penix succeeding. but again, I dont think its way off, depends which QB you like more I guess @Rareluck

Rareluck 8 hours ago

my team is solid, but underperformed like Hell this past season. I need RB with only Breece and Chuba, everything else is GTG

Rareluck 8 hours ago

12 team, very serious league

A440 8 hours ago

I have no doubt that JJM will be competent at the least. While I also believe Penix will be, I have no reason to believe either will be difference makers at the position. Since QBs largely perform the same in the vast middle tier, unless they’re a difference maker or a POS, it doesn’t really matter who you have (with a few outliers that are too streaky to be relied on). However, people don’t really think that way, so I’d ask for a third or late second as well. But yeah, I’d do that. Your main concern wil be whether JJM will get the start this year and stay healthy (but the health thing can easily be a concern for both).

ZakA1978 4 hours ago

I would. I like JJ more than penix anyway