Help needed gents! Was just offered this one. 1QB non TEP Give: JT, Jeudy, Hockenson Receive: McBride, Rice

I would just keep what you got tbh

Solid for McBride. I'd take that. I don't think the gap is that big between Hock and McBride but I like the price.

Meh. If it’s PPR, it’s fine, nothing spectacular. If it’s not PPR, there’s no way I do this deal. I frankly don’t see a huge gap between McB and Hock (Hock was coming off a year that he was coming off major injury, and usage increased more down the stretch, and he’s a LOT more in the red zone than McB). One thing I will point out, however, is that “buying low” on a player actually means you have to get him at a decent price. To me, you’re actually paying a premium on Rice with the question marks surrounding him. Still has the legal issues over his head, but people are ignoring Worthy’s emergence toward the end of the year. Yes, they serve different roles, but that’s ignoring that there are only so many opportunities. Throw in the emergence of Gray and now Rice competes directly with Kelce AND Gray for the same targets.

im not trying to talk you into anything, and would most definitely rather have had a better number two, like I said, you gotta get lucky to win it all

I think I would take the Rice side, I expect him to take up where he left off and finish in the top 10 or better and McBride is a position hammer,

Pretty similar in value to your last one I think. I can see this going either way. Would want to make sure I had a plan to address rb depth closer to the season if I pulled the trigger here. I still give JT 2-3 yrs of top production. Rice should have the greater longevity though.

It’s a risky move I agree. Brown isn’t making me feel too good so kind of hoping to get ahead of things and get rice onboard and can trade one of my wrs after the draft for a reasonable rb at a fair price is my thoughts

I don’t trust hall going into next year especially with the questions at QB. So with saying that I wouldn’t be selling Taylor right now which is the worry possible time to sell a rb

I wouldn’t take this trade

Beauty thanks a lot for your time and thoughts gents greatly appreciated 🍻

@JMOTED @A440 @cwmoorez @garden91 @Stxmatt Thank you for your thoughts and time, gentlemen I really really appreciate it! What would you guys think about trading Hock and Jeudy for Mcbride?

yeah, I didn't take anything you said in a negative way at all, and didn't mean to come across that way if I did, the way I see buy low is getting a player cheaper than I believe his value will be, I consider ADP and KTC values but two have lied to me before, lol, I have nothing but respect for your take and think a difference of opinion is a good thing, for who had the question to begin with and for me